Light Guard Punch
For a dinner party last New Year’s Eve, I made USS Richmond Punch and for a similar party this New Year’s Eve, I tried Light Guard Punch.
I’d made this one once before for a small get-together at my apartment, but I wanted to reprise it because it was delicious, easy, and turned out well, and I figured it’d go over well with a slightly larger group. I think it did. In short, where the USS Richmond is more or less a red punch, the Light Guard is a yellow punch: sweet but not sickly, crisp, very citrusy (actual citrus + a majority of alcohols with strong citrus notes = very citrusy), and of course golden-colored, on account of the many straw- or amber-hued liquids.
Although I used David Wondrich’s suggestions for assembly (and precise amount of sugar) from his book Punch, I’m pleased that this recipe can be replicated more or less exactly how it would have tasted when it was published in 1862 in Jerry Thomas’s The Bartender’s Guide: How To Mix Drinks. I halved the recipe for our group of nine; the original 20-person recipe by Thomas is listed below with my consolidation of Wondrich’s instructions.
Sauternes, a French dessert wine, commonly comes in 375 mL half-bottles but I assume the “1 bottle” in the original recipe refers, like every other liquid ingredient, to a full 750 mL bottle. Some versions of the recipe I’ve seen don’t assume that but I have little use for leftover Sauternes and it’s the most expensive ingredient; I selected the cheapest half-bottle I could find, a Château Grillon 2009, and it still set me back $22. In another section of Punch, Wondrich admits there’s no such thing as a cheap Sauternes even though that’s what you want for punch, where it’s used “chiefly as a softening agent, to tame the brandy without making the Punch watery.” Instead, he suggests looking “for a dessert wine from the Loire area, such as a Coteaux de Layon,” but my short, less-than-thorough search turned up nothing cheaper than the Château Grillon.
I selected an equally cheap pale sherry, Tio Soto Fino, which costs under $6 and comes in a classy, opaque gold-colored bottle. (Hey, it served me fine last year, and this is punch not a highfalutin, savor-worthy cocktail.)
For Cognac, I used a Pitaud VSOP. Normally I’d dumb it down to a VS, but this was leftover from the USS Richmond Punch I made last New Year’s.
And for the topper, I hate Champagne and I’d rather support the Italians than the French so I used the dry, citrusy Mia Prosecco Colli Trevigiani, a staff pick at Astor Wines & Spirits and often on sale there for about $7 a bottle.
I can tell you this: fruit at the bottom of a punchbowl is always a sodden treat, but I found that by merely waving around some of the supersaturated pineapple rings from the dregs of this recipe and the fumes alone made me more tipsy. As my brother has noted, “It wasn’t named punch due to its soft caress.”
Light Guard Punch
- 3 bottles of Champagne
- 1 bottle of pale sherry
- 1 bottle of Cognac
- 1 bottle of Sauternes
- 1 pineapple, sliced
- 4 lemons, sliced
- Slice the lemons and pineapple into thin rings. Steep them in the cognac for three to four hours in the refrigerator. Just before serving, in a two-gallon punch bowl, dissolve four ounces superfine sugar in the sherry and Sauternes. Add the cognac and fruit mixture. Then add a large block of ice and the Champagne. Add more sugar to taste, if necessary.
- Serves 20.