Cat Power
In line for the Cat Power concert tonight at Irving Plaza, I witnessed the smoothest and quickest pickup ever.
“What kind of shoes are those?” the girl in front of me asked a guy standing near her.
She was a short, jet-set dressed young lady in her late-20’s who strove to impress that she was cool or older, mentioning her “friends in Europe” up front while also revealing she said “like” too much. I would describe her hair as “expensive.” He, dressed all in black, resembled Liam Gallagher with a Type-B personality.
He explained they were a special brand of Japanese acupuncture sneakers, “with pressure points in the soles.” I forget the name of the brand, but they’re footwear streamlined to more closely resemble socks. They were sleek and solid black and even the laces looked as if they had been designed in a wind tunnel.
“Wow, I really like ’em,” she said. “Where do you get shoes like that?”
“Online. Or in stores,” he said. “Mostly online.”
“So where are you from?” she asked.
“New York and New Jersey,” he said. “Mostly New York,” he added quickly.
And after that, two previous strangers began conversing freely, smiling and talking the whole time in line, even entering the concert together, a cartoon heart hovering above their heads. So maybe it didn’t work out, but it was impressive to behold in slow motion like that. Inspiring, too. So it’s that easy, I thought to myself. All I need are expensive shoes and the look of a British rockstar.
And then, via a clumsy segue, there’s Cat Power, who doesn’t resemble a rockstar, but is in fact a mousy 34-year-old woman named Chan Marshall. She doesn’t even act much like a musician; she acts like an eight-year-old girl. I was forewarned of her precociousness. Earlier in her career, she was infamous for stopping shows, walking off stage, and starting then stopping songs, all the while barely acknowledging or insulting the audience. Stagefright, mental issues, drugs, alcohol, general diva-ness, a combo of some or all: the reviewers bandied about possible causes, but no satisfactory answer was given. I had a ticket for a concert of hers in February when her label suddenly announced it had cancelled her entire U.S. tour “due to health reasons.”
I hadn’t witnessed her behavior before tonight but she is one strange lady. She had the audience on edge when the show started late with two instrumentals by her backing band. Then she didn’t appear until the musicians recycled through the first verse of the opening song and re-announced her, twice. She eventually sauntered onstage with a lit Parliament and a Solo cup of hot tea in one hand, while with the other she alternately grabbed the mike and presented abstract gestures to punctuate the song’s rhythm and lyrics. She put down her cigarette and drink after the opener, then busied her hands between songs waving to random people in the audience, playing with her hair and fiddling with her lavender kerchief.
These tics extended to her between-song banter, not one word of which made a lick of sense, whether she was rambling about her jet on the roof of the building or blowing raspberries like Lily Tomlin on Sesame Street. “It’s Saturday Night Live,” she said in a deep voice at one point. “Jim Belushi. Newt Gingrich!” I couldn’t tell if any of these non-sequiturs were merely obtuse or private jokes, or just sweet nothings.
During a song later in the set, she grabbed the guitar off one of her musicians, played it for a verse, then decided she didn’t want it anymore, so she held it from her outstretched arm as she continued to sing. Both the keyboardist and a stagehand attempted to convey, via a series of fevered glances and hand motions, who should grab it.
I felt for that keyboardist, the de facto bandleader who alternated songs between a Hammond organ and a piano. When he was on the piano, his back was to Cat, and he spent most of the last halves of songs with his head twisted completely around, while still playing, to catch a signal that the song was ending.
Ah, but the music. On her newest album and this tour, she’s backed by the Memphis Rhythm Band, a brassy sound of the ’70s via seasoned sessionmen including Mabon “Teenie” Hodges, guitarist for Al Green during his glory years and cowriter of “Here I Am, Come and Take Me” and “Love and Happiness.”
The sound mix emphasized the drums, keys and guitars, but squashed the three-woman string section and much of the two-woman vocal backup. Most of the songs seemed to be from Cat’s newest album, The Greatest, which I’m not familiar with, but things heated up when the band left the stage and she hit the piano solo for her cover of the Velvet Underground’s “I Found a Reason,” which sounds nothing like the original but is one of her most haunting songs. She took to a guitar solo, too, to crank out “House of the Rising Sun,” oddly. Most of her songs are like beautiful dirges and she makes other people’s songs her own. Her husky voice hangs and swoops, extending words with a kind of sad longing. It’s good music in small doses, but stacked up in concert has a narcotic effect.
Things picked up when Teenie and the band reclaimed the stage and he knocked out a song of his own. It reinvigorated the crowd and Cat came back for a great final quartet of tunes. First was another cover, “Naked, if I Want To” by Moby Grape, the best song on her compilation, The Covers Record, which she followed with the peppy “Nude as the News” (if memory serves), both songs fuller and more energetic with a full band backing. From there she segued directly into a cover of the Stones’ “Satisfaction” that got the crowd clapping. (That’s about as crazy as you’re going to get for this kind of music among trendy young white people.)
Everyone was still clapping the “Satisfaction” beat after the song ended, so Cat launched into an acapella version of Gnarls Barkley’s “Crazy,” an unexpected choice for a woman who counts Bob Dylan and Skip Spence among her top influences. The same girl who didn’t want to get on the stage earlier now didn’t want to get off. They had to turn on the house lights and bring down the curtain (actually a screen on which is projected a moving starfield). But they left her mike on and she kept singing from behind the screen. The audience wondered whether it should leave, but eventually the disembodied voice stopped and everyone filed out, remarking that she’s gotten a lot better.