Your Compilation CD Perturbs Me
I like music and I buy CDs. Lots of CDs. No, I don’t think I’m better than you. Somedays I think it’s a foolish investment. I probably buy an average of two CDs a week, mostly used, and I’m proud that many of them, when their cost is divided by their number of tracks, I pay less than I would have had I purchased album from the iTunes Store.
So, wait; I guess I do think I’m better than you.
But really in this space I just want to grouse about compilation CDs, which encompass greatest hits packages, soundtracks and other such collections. I buy a lot of these and I love them because they can serve as great "mix tapes" or collections of tracks that I might be hard-pressed or inconvenienced to find separately. But there can be issues and here are the four main ones.
The Gapless Album. Offenders: the Another Late Night series and the MTV Party To Go series. Gapless albums, which contain no pauses between tracks, are a fact of the music world: many live albums are gapless and classic studio gapless albums include The Beatles’ Abbey Road and many by Pink Floyd. I don’t own any albums from the MTV Party To Go series but they were all produced in the mid-90s, those heady days when powerful, mystical DJs roamed the earth with milkcrates of vinyl in tow. An album where one track flows seamlessly into another? Wow! It’s like bringing your favorite club’s DJ home to your living room, in living stereophonic sound! Nowadays, nobody wants or needs a compilation album where everything segues into everything else because everyone’s trying to make his or her own compilation. Rip a track from a gapless album and it’s tainted by the tail end of the track before it. Give it up, gapless comps; it’s not 1993 any more. We can segue and crossfade ourselves.
The Live Track. Offenders: countless “Greatest Hits” albums. I’m only partially embarrassed to admit I picked up a dirt-cheap copy of the Jay & Silent Bob Strike Back soundtrack because I wanted the seldom-anthologized "Jungle Love" by The Time. Nowhere on the tracklisting on the back of the CD is it listed as a live track. And of course it is.
The Poorly Labeled Alternate Version. Offenders: most recently for me, the Tommy Boy Hip Hop Roots compilation, which purports to be a primer of a dozen most-often sampled tracks by hip hop and rap pioneers of the ’80s and ’90s (“Think (About It)” by Lyn Collins, “Give It Up or Turnit a Loose” by James Brown). In fact it contains mostly edited/remixed version of those tracks, indicated only by a miniscule credit line on the back of the CD that I initially missed.
The Almost-There Compilation. Sometimes this will happen with soundtracks that don’t include the most popular cuts from the movie or a missing a bunch. Even worse on the non-soundtrack side: trying to find a single album greatest-hits package of certain artists. It can be a nightmare, particularly if the band/artist was on a number of labels. Nine Simone is a prime example. The Kinks are another. My old editor at my job is also a Kinks fan and we were discussing this. At length.
At a glance, the best Kinks comp is The Ultimate Collection, a 2002 two-disc import from Sanctuary Records. I snagged one from the Virgin Megastore on Times Square for a mere $10 earlier this year. Despite my rambling below, as of today, it remains the best Kinks greatest-hits package and you should buy it immediately.
But... there’s always a but. Ultimate doesn’t include the Kinks first two singles, a cover of Little Richard’s “Long Tall Sally” and their first original composition, “You Still Want Me.” Both are included on Sanctuary’s The Singles Collection, the remaining 23 tracks of which are duplicated on The Ultimate Collection. Damn you, Sanctuary.
And although the second disc of The Ultimate Collection includes much of the Kinks’ best work from the late-’70s through the mid-’80s (“Come Dancing,” “(Wish I Could Fly Like) Superman,” “Living On A Thin Line”), it’s missing key tracks from that era (“A Rock ‘n’ Roll Fantasy,” “Father Christmas”) that are included on Come Dancing With The Kinks: The Best of The Kinks 1977-1986. So I gotta own that one, too.
Then there are missing stay singles and B-sides (“Fancy,” “This is Where I Belong”), which appear on none of the above comps but which are on the older two-disc Kink Kronikles best-of, more than half of which is duplicated on The Ultimate Collection. Don’t even get me started about absent album favorites (“Picture Book,” “Big Sky”).
The bottom line: I must own at least six CDs with much overlap to rip a truly ultimate oeuvre of the Kinks. Someone needs to remaster all this shit and slap it on a deluxe limited-edition five-disc set packed in a velvet box containing extensive liner notes by David Fricke and genuine replica Ray Davies paisley scarf just in time for 2007 holiday giving.