20 Songs About New York City
Compiling lists of songs about New York is not a new thing. You can Google several sites listing dozens and Rhino even released a lousy compilation a few years back. Here are my own top-20 New York songs, in no particular order. You may notice the absence of several obvious tracks by Frank Sinatra, Billy Joel and Don Henley. That’s because Frank Sinatra, Billy Joel and Don Henley suck.
Ace Frehley :: New York Groove (1978)
“Stop at third and forty-three, exit to the night/It’s gonna be ecstasy, this place was meant for me.” Ace busts forth from KISS on his solo debut and cranks out a joyous ode to the city’s nightlife.
Beastie Boys :: An Open Letter To NYC (2004)
“We’re doing fine on the 1 and 9 line.” The Boys’ valentine to tha five boroughs; they still got it. This song gets me all misty and wistful, then I snap out of it when I realize I actually am living here.
Belle & Sebastian :: Piazza, New York Catcher (2003)
“Piazza, New York catcher, are you straight or are you gay?” A silly, bittersweet song on acoustic guitar from those mopey Scots.
Bill Withers :: Harlem (1971)
“Summer night in Harlem/Man, it’s really hot.” It’s true. Ask Jimi sometime about the fun we had hauling an air conditioner all the way up there.
Bob Dylan :: Talkin’ New York (1962)
“I swung on to my old guitar/Grabbed hold of a subway car/And after a rocking, reeling, rolling ride/I landed up on the downtown side; Greenwich Village.” A freewheeling folksong off Dylan’s first album, it fits me to a T with lyrics like: “after weeks and weeks of hangin’ around/I finally got a job in New York town.” And it’s funny, too, particularly the final verse: “So one mornin’ when the sun was warm/I rambled out of New York town/Pulled my cap down over my eyes/And headed out for the western skies/So long, New York/Howdy, East Orange.” Ha ha!
Galaxie 500 :: Fourth Of July (1990)
“I got drunk and looked at the Empire State Building/It was no bigger than a nickel.” The great overlooked NYC song. I listened to this a lot before moving here and even more after because the lyrics seemed so poignant: “I never thought that I would end up here/Maybe I should just change my style/But I feel all right when you smile.”
Harry Nilsson :: I Guess The Lord Must Be In New York City (1969)
In December 2003, the last time I visited New York before moving here, I bought a Nilsson greatest hits CD and listened to this track a lot. It’s not as fresh now, but any song with a banjo ends up having that effect on me. Trivia time: This song was supposed to be the theme for Midnight Cowboy, but Schlesinger liked “Everybody’s Talkin’” better, even though it’s a Badfinger cover. Such is life.
Interpol :: NYC (2002)
“New York cares!” You feel as if you’re soaring over the skyscrapers on this one.
Le Tigre :: My My MetroCard (1998)
“Next stop/Christopher Street/Next stop/Transfer to the/Next stop/A, C, or E.” A rockin’ blast of a song about my favorite card in my wallet (sorry, Caruso). And the grrrls even diss Giuliani for boarding up all those strip clubs.
Leonard Cohen :: Chelsea Hotel No. 2 (1974)
“I remember you well in the Chelsea Hotel.” A wistful Cohen song about certain illicit activities in said hotel.
M. Doughty :: Thank You, Lord, For Sending Me The F Train (2000)
I think all New Yorkers have felt this way at one time or another about their own subway train, whether the F or not.
Magnetic Fields :: The Luckiest Guy On The Lower East Side (1999)
Downtown gets all the good songs.
PJ Harvey :: You Said Something (2000)
“On a rooftop in Brooklyn/At one in the morning/Watching the lights flash/In Manhattan/I see five bridges/The Empire State Building.” The album this one’s from, Stories From The City, Stories From The Sea, is mostly about New York, but “You Said Something” is the epitome. A beautiful, soaring song.
Prince :: Uptown (1980)
“Everybody’s going/Uptown/It’s where I wanna be/Uptown/U can set your mind free, yeah/Uptown.” I don’t know which city Prince had in mind when he wrote this (Minneapolis?), but I like to think it’s New York. One of the first times I took the NQRW, running late, I accidentally got on an express train and missed my stop at 8th St., only to realize I needed to get back uptown just as the train sped past the Prince St. stop — at the exact moment my iPod started playing “Uptown.” That’s fucked up.
Serge Gainsbourg :: New York-USA (1964)
“Empire State Building, oh cést haut/Rockfeller Center, oh cést haut.” Yes, Serge, they are high, aren’t they. Essentially the French version of TMBG’s “New York City” (see below), containing a list of landmarks as a mighty paean.
Simon & Garfunkel :: The Only Living Boy In New York (1970)
I mainly like this because the multi-tracked chorus harmonies sound like S&G doing their best Beach Boys impression.
Simon & Garfunkel :: Bleeker Street (1964)
“Fog’s rollin’ in off the East River bank/Like a shroud it covers Bleecker Street.” I hope Paul didn’t purposely misspell the name of the street in the song’s title just to be clever. Then again, it was the ‘60s.
They Might Be Giants :: New York City (1996)
“’Cause everyone’s your friend in New York City/And everything looks beautiful when you’re young and pretty.” A cover by a little-known band named Cub. The chorus is more infectious than Ebola.
Tom Waits :: Downtown Train (1985)
“The downtown trains are full/With all those Brooklyn girls/They try so hard to break out of their little worlds.” I’ve always wanted to punch people who like Rod’s version of this song, moreso those who think it’s Rod’s own song. Tom should just cut out the middleman and punch Rod himself.
The Velvet Underground :: I’m Waiting For The Man (1967)
“Up to Lexington, 125/Feel sick and dirty, more dead than alive.” Lou Reed’s adventures scoring smack from East Harlem’s only express stop. One of the first songs I heard in a bar after I moved here. Its constantly pounded piano gets the bodies goin’ on the dance floor.